|The Shakespearean Cast of War of the Planet of the Apes|
I am definitely willing to suspend my disbelief and accept the premise that in some apocalyptic world, apes may be as smart as humans. Heck, I think they could give our Congress a run for their money right now. It's part of a long running series of movies that have mainly flopped, but they keep making enough money to pay for the next generation of gorilla suits. The latest installment is quirky and thin on plot, but I was interested in the movie all the way through. Not better than Wonder Woman, but maybe close to Spider-Man.
Surprisingly the acting is at a very high level, and it is possible to really believe in the characters even though they all are apes. They are engaged in a battle with humans, and struggle with their temptation to give into racism (specie-ism?). I didn't think it was a war though. You're supposed to believe that there are almost no humans or apes left in the world after a series of apocalyptic events. Still, the main drama involves a small group of apes, and maybe a battalion of humans. I found that confusing. Why is a battle with just a few characters considered a world war? Meanwhile we find out that there is some other group of humans left, probably the Russians, though they never really do much in the movie.
But okay, if you're willing to settle for a Battle for a county involving apes and humans, it's a decent movie. It could just as well be a cowboys and Indians movie, with the Cowboys tending towards treachery, and the Indians showing much higher morality.
You could also draw a parallel with Hogan's Heros, in which the humans play the part of the Nazis. They are mainly bad, but not very bright and do a lot of dumb things that allow the apes to take advantage of them. To some extent the apes are also kind of dumb. I mean if you take some of them prisoner, maybe next time you will remember to post a guard to prevent them from plotting an escape.
The movie succeeds as a drama, probably not Oscar material, but not that far from it either. As a science fiction story it's a bit of dud because the story line is weak. The battle scenes are fairly realistic, and there may be some blood and guts spilled. Maybe your ten year old doesn't need to see that. But if you like science fiction, apes, cowboys vs Indians and Hogan's Heroes, you will like this movie. Overall I give it a B.